Equine Law & Business Letter
Articles
Most Recent
A summary of legislation and rulings from July – September 2026.
A hunter trainer was censured, fined $2,000, and lost her horse’s prize money after it tested positive for altrenogest (Regu-Mate), which is banned in male horses. The USEF Hearing Committee rejected her theory that the horse was exposed while out on trial.
A vet who treats both thoroughbreds and quarter horses was charged under HISA for carrying Sarapin and AMP in his truck. An FTC judge upheld the Sarapin violation but ruled HIWU never proved AMP is banned, sending the case back for new penalties.
A young thoroughbred trainer faced a 46-month HISA suspension after testosterone positives and a banned supplement found in his inherited tack room. On FTC review, the suspension was cut to 20 months, but the judge still faulted him for accepting an evasive vet’s answers.
A junior show jumper’s horse tested positive for betamethasone 18 days after hock injections, well past the FEI’s 7-day detection guideline. The FEI Tribunal ruled that relying on vets is no defense, but cut his suspension to one month because he was a junior.
An eventing rider’s horse tested positive for trazodone after a fatal fall at an FEI three-star event. She traced it to a scoop a barn employee used to dose another horse, but the FEI still suspended her for two months.
A Saudi endurance rider’s horse collapsed and died at an FEI event, and its blood showed three prohibited substances the treating vets said they did not give. The FEI Tribunal rejected his explanation and imposed a six-month suspension and fines.
Two Bahraini endurance riders cleared themselves of an FEI atenolol positive by proving a fired groom crushed the drug into their horses’ feed as revenge. The groom confessed and was convicted, and the FEI Tribunal accepted the sabotage defense.
A California exhibitor received multiple USEF Yellow Warning Cards, a censure, and a $2,000 fine after letting her dog run off leash in a warm-up area at a licensed competition. Her response to the official involved did not help.
USEF suspended a North Carolina trainer for one month, fined him $2,000, and put him on probation after video showed him using an unethical training technique at a private facility. USEF rules can reach conduct away from the show grounds.
A Texas Arabian trainer expelled from USEF over the neglect of 54 horses asked to be reinstated. The Hearing Committee said no, finding no proof of rehabilitation or remorse, and extended his expulsion until at least July 2028.
A federal court dismissed dressage trainer Michael Barisone’s lawsuit claiming USEF failed to act on complaints about a student before he shot her in 2019. The ruling explains when USEF rules apply outside competition and what its Safe Sport Policy requires.
A Louisiana parish banned a show management company from running barrel races at its public arena after the company raised safety concerns. A federal jury found the ban violated the company’s due process rights, and the court added $105,000 in attorneys’ fees.
A ranching couple who bred Appaloosas and Quarter Horses convinced the Tax Court their horse operation was run for profit, not as a hobby. Hard daily work and modest tax savings outweighed years of losses and spotty records.
A horse broke away from its handler at a Texas vet clinic, ran into the road, and collided with a car. The driver sued the clinic, but the appeals court upheld dismissal because she offered no expert testimony or proof the clinic let the horse run at large.
Maine’s highest court ruled that the state’s Equine Activity Liability Act protects only equine sponsors, professionals, and participants. A rider thrown from her mule after a nearby UTV crash can sue the driver for negligence.
Can a riding stable be sued when a loose dog spooks a lesson horse? An Illinois appeals court said no. Under the state’s Equine Activity Liability Act, a horse’s reaction to other animals is an inherent risk of riding.
A federal court ruled that Easttown Township’s special event permit ordinance violated the Devon Horse Show’s First Amendment rights. Devon won $3 in nominal damages and attorney’s fees, but no refund of the fees it paid.
A dressage trainer has filed an equine veterinary malpractice suit after a fertility clinic placed egg cells from her deceased mare in contaminated media, ending her hopes of a foal from that mare. The case is pending in federal court in Florida.
A North Carolina jury ordered a horse trainer to pay $100,000 after his gun went off during a scuffle with his son and killed a $70,000 racehorse. The appeals court upheld the verdict, including punitive damages.
Archives

Vet Clinic Seeks Enforcement Of Non-Compete
A multi-jurisdictional veterinary clinic has secured an injunction prohibiting one of its former veterinarians from practicing equine veterinary medicine within numerous counties

Arizona Court of Appeals Reinstates Sales Fraud Lawsuit
An Arizona Court of Appeals recently reinstated the lawsuit brought by a disgruntled purchaser of a lame horse. The purchaser claimed the

Quarter Horse Breeders Fail To Prove “Profit Motive” To IRS
The IRS audited a couple, who operated a Quarter Horse breeding and training business, for the 2017-2019 tax years. The IRS determined

Supreme Court of Michigan Agrees To Interpret Equine Activity Liability Act
The Supreme Court of Michigan has agreed to review the dismissal of a personal injury lawsuit brought by a woman who was

Mountain or Molehill? That Is The Question.
A Louisiana appellate court has reinstated a personal injury lawsuit that was dismissed by a trial court, sending the case back to

Kids Fall Off Sometimes
A Maryland horse trainer was absolved of liability for the injuries sustained by a child who fell off on a trail ride

Supreme Court Of Iowa Affirms Dismissal Of Personal Injury Lawsuit; Admits Iowa’s Immunity Statute Yields “Harsh Result”
A horse trainer in Iowa asked one of his students to film him operating an antique horse-drawn sickle mower. After about forty

Federal Appellate Court Rules HISA Unconstitutional
The United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit recently struck down the Horseracing Integrity and Safety Act (“HISA”) on Constitutional