Equine Law & Business Letter
Articles
Most Recent
A summary of legislation and rulings from April – May 2026.
A woman hired a trainer to tame and train a wild, “unhandled” mustang she adopted through the Bureau of Land Management. Dissatisfied with the horse’s condition after 4 months, she moved the horse to another barn and sued the trainer for $6,000, alleging the trainer had committed “animal cruelty.”
A New York court refused to dismiss the personal injury lawsuit of a rider who claimed a dude ranch employee torqued her knee while helping her mount the horse she was given to ride.
The lawsuit was initiated by an experienced horseback rider who participated in advanced riding at defendant’s dude ranch for two days.
A federal appellate court recently dismissed a challenge to SafeSport that was brought by three trainers who had been sanctioned by SafeSport for violating its code of conduct. The trainers filed a federal lawsuit against the United States Center for Safesport (“SafeSport”), the United States Olympic & Paralympic Committee (“USOC”) and the United States Equestrian Federation, Inc. (“USEF”).
The Virginia trial court dismissed an injured rider’s personal injury lawsuit against a stable on the basis of a pre-injury liability release signed by the rider. Relying on the signed release and Virginia’s Equine Activity Liability Act (“EALA”), the trial court concluded the rider could not sue. The rider appealed.
Renown Thoroughbred racehorse trainer, Todd Pletcher, recently appealed a $1,000 fine and 10-day suspension that was imposed on him by the New York Gaming Commission (“New York Racing”) after a horse he trained tested positive for Meloxicam after finishing in second place in a race held at the Saratoga Racecourse.
A New Jersey racehorse trainer unsuccessfully appealed stiff penalties imposed by the New Jersey Racing Commission after a post-race urine sample taken from a horse he trained tested positive for three banned substances: Oxycodone, an opioid used to treat pain; Carisoprodol, a medication used to treat musculoskeletal pain; and Meprobamate, a medication used to treat anxiety and insomnia.
Archives
USEF Expels Member Who Left Colicking Horse Tied In Stall
USEF expelled a trainer whose conduct the Hearing Committee found “contributed to the unintentional death” of a show horse in her care, custody, and control.
Veterinarian Expelled For Malpractice and Animal Cruelty
The United States Equestrian Federation (“USEF”) has expelled a member for violating the USEF Code of Conduct after a Texas court found her guilty of felony animal cruelty to a mare to whom the veterinarian was providing post-surgical care.
According to the Hearing Committee’s decision, the member’s license to practice
Trainer Sues After Being Disciplined For Verbal Altercation With Steward
The Supreme Court of New Mexico has ruled that a trainer, who was disciplined after a verbal altercation with a steward, may have no legal recourse against the New Mexico Racing Commission (“NMRC”).
According to the Court, the trainer held a license issued by the NMRC and wanted to hire
Arabian Horse Breeders Fail To Prove Profit Motive
The United States Tax Court recently sustained the IRS’s disallowance of loss deductions a Louisiana couple claimed were attributable to their Arabian horse activities. The IRS had audited the couple for the years 2004-2009 and determined that they were not engaged in their Arabian horse activity with the requisite profit
Trainer Prevails In Owner’s Lawsuit Over Failure To Claim Racehorse
A racing enthusiast sued his trainer for failing to claim a racehorse he wanted. The case went to trial in a Maryland state court with the trainer emerging victorious on all counts. The trial court’s ruling was affirmed on appeal.
According to the appellate court’s decision,
Horse Trailer and Camper Not “Motor Vehicles” For Purposes of UIM Coverage
A South Carolina appellate court affirmed a trial court’s resolution of an insurance coverage dispute in favor of an insurance company that declined to offer underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage on an insured’s camper and horse trailer.
The trial court had granted the insurance company